taylor vs tyler

[The Mac]

so its official the edmonton oilers will be drafting first in the 2010 nhl draft so now the big question
do u draft taylor hall or tyler seguin
in my opinion taylor hall should be the number one pick he has that game changing abiility that
tyler just dont have. and during the playoff series with the 2 of them tyler disappeared while taylor prospered
i hope there isnt a repeat performance by the oilers they always waste there top picks (have u heard of steve kelly, jasion bosignmore no me neither) plus taylor has great chemistry with another young one that the oilers have in jordon eberle
lets hope the oilers get hall

[Swinny]

Well... it all really depends on what the teams want, but I agree that Taylor Hall seems to be the better overall player and I think he could help the Oilers out the most. I think either play could help them out though, really and I don't think picking Tyler first would be a mistake necessarily.

As far as the Oilers making bad picks, they have made some... but they've also drafted guys like Paul Coffey, Grant Fuhr, Jason Arnott, Ryan Smyth and others.

[The Mac]

yes but that was under the old scouting team
since barry fraser left its all been mostly crap
except for cogs and gagner