WOW Really? I thought 3-2 Edgar and pushing it 4-1 with the 5th being the exception and hardest to call. But they both look good and will be interesting to see what happens next :).
Printable View
WOW Really? I thought 3-2 Edgar and pushing it 4-1 with the 5th being the exception and hardest to call. But they both look good and will be interesting to see what happens next :).
Nice job Trav, ty :)
thanks
GARBAGE!! as bad as it is to say I dont think any title fight should go to a draw. I think if it is that close... which it was, i think you should let the champ be the winner. Which is what I think happened in Machida v. Rua
But the champ still keeps his title in a draw anyway, so...Quote:
Originally Posted by Punisher
I don't think they should just give it to the champ if it's that close and I don't think that the judges should lean towards the champ just because they hold the belt. Both guys should be on equal playing fields, no matter which one is the champion and which is the challenger.
And after thinking it over, I actually support the draw because really, neither guy deserved to lose that fight. If Edgar won and kept his title, there'd always be the question of if he deserved it and if Maynard won there would always be the question of if he REALLY beat the champ, so maybe this is for the best. There's going to be a rematch to decide once and for all who deserves the title, so I think everything works out.
ya but petis now has to wait even longer
Fantastic show.. Loved the first bout, and I am a fan of Clay Guido xD. The second bout wasn't much imo, but still somewhat enjoyable. The third bout was one-sided and slightly boring to begin with, but 1/2 of the second round, and the 3rd round were quite intense. I've only seen the first 3 bouts, and I'm very impressed.
You only saw the first three? You definitely have to watch Edgar vs. Maynard then, definitely the best fight of the night and one of the best fights I've seen in awhile.Quote:
Originally Posted by John
jusrt watched the fights and in my not so expert opinion.... Maynard was robbed