Jeff Hardy was great in the WWE. Back in 2000 - 2002 that is. I believe that was his prime. He was putting on some incredible displays. But you got to notice something there. It was in the tag team division where he was part of the team 'The Hardy Boyz' with Matt Hardy. And another thing is that the matches were all high risk/hardcore. But when he did infact go to singles wrestling he wasn't part of gimmick matches anymore. That is why he began 'falling down the ladder'. He was taken completely out of his element.

TNA however actually gave Hardy a chance to showcase his talent in singles compitition. This was in hardcore matches. Such as Monsters Ball, matches again Rhino etc. Because of TNA's style Hardy started rising again. But you have to think about Hardy as a person. The guys a joke. I'm sure he's some sort of druggy, he no shows events. He's just an idiot. Thats the reason why he didn't get his oppertunaty in TNA to become the Champion. Hardy fucked his own career up. Not anyone else.

So the question to me is unanswerable. He wasn't in TNA for long and he was in WWE for quite a while. Doesn't ballance out enough to have a fair answer.