Big Evil where have you been all my life. I was sure there weren't any people who thought rationally about wrestling and here you are.
I personally do not enjoy Cena that much. The reason I don't enjoy him is not because he is a "bad wrestler" because what we are talking about here is-- a person who is professionally trained to make a match interesting and compelling by utilizing his natural charisma, natural athletic ability, and timing to help me suspend disbelief and get into a wrestling match.With my definition of a Professional Wrestler on the books, I go through long spells where I find myself really not getting into a Cena match, and I think it is because he is often booked like Superman. So I don't think he is a poor wrestler I just think they book him too damn strong sometimes and half the guys he faces aren't believable competitors.
Now with that in account Cena has had some great matches with Shawn Michaels, HHH, Kurt Angle, Orton, and a handful of other guys because it was compelling and I believed either guy could win. Cena knows how to work a match, and according to all the old timers in WWE he is constantly asking how he can improve, what more can you ask for? The guy is a mega star who has had a bunch of good to great matches and he knows how to work a crowd...good wrestler in my opinion.
I would like to see a point by point reasoning as to your hatred for Cena because I think it is unwarranted. If we are talking talent here I'd say Cena is way more talented than a good portion of your list up there.
Some of your list up there get by because they utilize exciting moves but they just kind of throw them out there without a thought as to timing or psychology and I just don't think that is talent. Being able to successfully pull off a dangerous move does not a great wrestler make.