This is always a great argument, so I'm posting. I'm going to list some players and you say weather you think they're hall of fame material or not. Explenations would be greatly appreciated.


Troy Aikmen

Michael Irvin

Tom Brady (If he stopped playing today)

Terrell Davis

Tom Brady

Adam Vinaterie

Warren Moon

Chris Carter

Ray Lewis

Those are just some names I've discussed recently. If you have more please post them. I'll post my answers after someone else post. I don't want to clutter the names with my opinions.