TNA Wrestling reportedly had another major name in mind for Moose’s open challenge at Bound For Glory before Max Caster stepped up to face the former world champion.

Sheamus recently became a free agent after his WWE contract expired. This ended his run with the company that began in the mid-2000s. The former multi-time world champion had turned down a restructured contract extension before his departure.

Caster ultimately answered Moose’s open challenge at Bound For Glory on October 11, making his TNA debut after leaving AEW. However, the appearance generated significant backlash because of a controversial reference in his entrance rap.

Moose ultimately defeated Caster in a competitive match.

According to False Finish HQ, Sheamus was TNA’s preferred choice for the surprise opponent in Moose’s open challenge before Caster entered the picture. The report has sparked speculation about what could have been a major debut for the former WWE Champion.

Sheamus, whose real name is Stephen Farrelly, officially became a free agent following the expiration of his WWE contract. He spent nearly two decades with the promotion, winning multiple championships and establishing himself as one of its prominent stars.

Meanwhile, Caster’s TNA debut has become a source of controversy. During his entrance rap at Bound For Glory, he referenced dropping bombs and Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, prompting criticism amid reports of attacks at King Khalid International Airport.

Fightful Select subsequently reported that Caster’s controversial rap had not been approved by TNA executives, who were reportedly unhappy with the situation. His future with the company was described as uncertain, with potential implications for upcoming tapings.